Thursday, February 28, 2019

Giovanni Bellini's Doge Leonardo Loredan

GIOVANNI BELLINI's DOGE LEONARDO LOREDAN

The National Gallery in London has an exquisite portrait that Giovanni Bellini
painted of Leonardo Loredan in 1501, just when Loredan became Doge of Venice. Doges (Dukes) were elected for life in the 16th century, and Loredan stayed in the post from 1501 until 1521, twenty years, longer than many other Doges.
The portrait is exquisite for many reasons:
1) It captures the lifelike features of the man, so that his fellow Venetians could
identify him. From other portraits done of him by other artists, it is reasonable to
assume that Bellini made an accurate account of his face and dress. Both Carpaccio and Catena did painted portraits where the features seem the same  though the paintings are not as skillful.
 




Leonardo Loredan is age 65, and the life experiences of that many years show on his face. Bellini paints him at a certain moment in time. He has just become Doge, after years of serving in several capacities in the Venetian government. He began as a lawyer working on the banking oversight committee called the "Giudici di Petizion"(Judges of Petitions), then was involved in foreign policy in the Collegio dei Savi, and later was Podesta di Padova, the governor of Padua, the large city which was part of the Venetian mainland. Before being selected Doge, he had also been part of what we might call the "Cabinet" as a Procuratore di San Marco. Bellini conveys Doge Loredan's understanding of human beings in his kind but shrewd eyes and in the mouth lines that only move up slightly.

         The portrait reflects his new-found power and is crafted before Loredan had to confront the most difficult events of his tenure. Two years after the portrait he had to give in to Turkish desires for Venetian territories in order to maintain peace with the Ottoman empire, and then in 1509, had to deal with war with the League of Cambrai, a deadly combination of French, Papal, and Holy Roman Imperial forces aligned against Venice, which resulted in losses of mainland Venetian cities. But those defeats are not recounted in this portrayal.
2) Bellini's portrait captures the features of a lifelike man, however. He seems alive in this portrait, as if in the next moment his eyes will blink and he will move off the wooden parapet.
That reality makes the portrait a treasure as a document of an historical figure who once lived in the 16th century, and of a person who seems alive even today, many centuries after his death date.
3) The portrait takes on the outline of a complete geometrical shape, a triangle.
The effect of that mathematical entity imposed on the figure is that the viewer
thinks they see the WHOLE of the man, not just his chest and head. We do not need to see his legs and shoes and the rest of his robe to comprehend him as
a complete person.
 

4) Bellini's painting captures the beauty of Venetian damask silk cloth in the formal dress worn by the Doge for official duties, and Bellini contrasts the delicate light and shade of the foliate gold print on the folds of the cloth

with the hard, round buttons that look like large hazelnuts or chestnuts. These are so beautifully rendered that viewers want to caress the silk and feel its texture and then compare the texture of the buttons. The sensuousness of both attracts and holds the viewer even more than the face of the Doge.
5) The portrait captures the official "corno," cap worn to distinguish the Doge as the leader in the Ducal Palace of Venice. This ducal headgear may have had its origins in images of Attis, the Phrygian god of vegetation:
 or in the cap of the ancient god Mithras:

 2nd century B.C. Mithras with bull, snake and dog, in British Museum, London.

Both suggest that Venice's power is associated with the Eastern Mediterranean.
The hard horn-shaped hat is covered in the same material as the gown below with an added gold filigree band. 
Underneath that, a white cap called the "camauro" protects the head from the hardness of the "corno." In Bellini's portrait not only do we see the camauro emerging out from under the "corno," but we see the strings of the camauro hanging down to suggest that the doge is not on official duty even though he is in official dress.

In other official doge portraits, the camauro strings are tied under the chin, as in this profile image of Doge Giovanni Mocenigo, a predecessor to Loredan.





6) At the same time that the portrait seems alive, it makes the Doge look like a piece of sculpture. In fact, this Doge had a sculpted portrait done of himself in terracotta by Danese Cattaneo that is extant in Birmingham's Art Gallery in England, and the figure is cut off at the chest slightly above the line where Bellini cuts the figure.


The sculptural quality exhibited in the painting shows Bellini competing with sculptors to paint a man who seems as three-dimensional as he would in a sculpture. The illusion of the cloth, the skin, the corno, the wooden parapet, all are a demonstration of the magic of painting in 2-dimensions a man who appears real and alive and full-bodied.
7) The artist is proud of his illusion and even enhances it by signing the work with his Latin name, Ioannes Bellinus, on a slip of paper that he imagines has
been folded twice, then unwrapped and attached to the wooden parapet.

All of the "conceit," "concetto," of the signature is a display of brilliance in painting that redounds to the painter's credit as much as the signature itself does. Strange that the signature should also be large enough that viewers might think it was the name of the sitter or the title of the work.
Since the artist earned his living from painting such illusions, Bellini's reputation depended upon other people knowing that he is the one who has painted this particular illusion. Even the Doge himself would have requested him for his skill, so the painter's acknowledgement of his identity in the signature is part of the value of the portrait for the Doge and for other viewers.
8) Why is this portrait such a powerful image, though? It is not just the sheen on the cloth, not just the wise expression from years of varying experiences in
government, not just the spectacular "corno" and "camauro," all of which contribute to the "photographic" sense of the person. Beyond that, and as in all great works of art, the artist has encapsulated the community that the Doge represents in his own portrait. He has done that by suggesting the Doge's bust portrait looks like a Venetian galley with a sail.
 




 
By imposing on the figure of the Doge the shape of the most important means of trade and transport in Venice, Bellini makes the Doge BECOME the whole of Venice and its sailing culture. The power of the Venetian state, then, is embodied in the portrait figure.
9) The white wispy strings that hang down from the camauro appeal to the viewer's desire to pull, as though we could control a whole sail from these
sheet lines. Their qualities of frivolity and randomness, untidiness and
interruption of the pure outline of the man contribute to the lifelike presence
in the scene. In them Bellini has caught the light, and with them, the next moment for this man. Their presence as lines of white in a sea of blue suggest
the wake of the ship of state.








Monday, February 18, 2019

MANTEGNA-BELLINI COMPARISON LIST




MANTEGNA-BELLINI COMPARISON LIST

A review of paintings by Mantegna and Giovanni Bellini reveals that they
often did similar subjects and rarely used the same medium. In this list I have paired similar subjects by both painters, with Mantegna on the left and Giovanni Bellini on the right. All the paintings I have found by Mantegna, apart from his frescoes in the Ducal Palace in Mantua, are painted in tempera, quite a conservative medium in Italy when he is painting in the 1490's. Giovanni Bellini, on the other hand, (except for the Agony in the Garden, where he is competing with Mantegna directly and uses tempera, and his fresco paintings for the Scuola and the Ducal Palace in Venice,) uses oil paint exclusively. Which means, perhaps, that when trying to determine if a painting is by Mantegna or Giovanni Bellini, medium is the first thing that should be checked.
Here is a partial list of similar painted subjects by the two artists:

Folded paper:

Mantegna, 1465-74-Camera degli                   Bellini, Sacra Conversazione, 1505
sposi, Mantua, ducal letter folded                                  Birmingham.                                        

Single Saints:
Mantegna, St. Mark  1448                   Giovanni Bellini, Fra Teodoro da Urbino
Stadel Museum, Frankfurt                   as St. Dominic  1515
                                                             Victoria and Albert Museum, London


 
Not quite a fair comparison since Mantegna's painting is one of his earliest, at age 17, and the Bellini painting is a year before he died, at age 89. That said, it seems that in the Fra Teodoro painting Bellini is nostalgic for his rival, Mantegna, and includes the lily and flowered-print backdrop with the book and
ledge in memory of him. (Mantegna died in 1506, a year before Gentile Bellini and 10 years years before Giovanni Bellini.)

2 subjects by these artists that we have discussed in a previous blog entry:
Presentation in the Temple 1454              Presentation in the Temple 1454
Gemaldegalerie, Berlin                             Fondazione Querini-Stampalia, Venice


Agony in the Garden 1455                               Agony in the Garden 1455
NGL (National Gallery,London)                       NGL



                                                                         
Madonna and Sleeping Child:  1455                     Madonna of the Trees: 1487
Gemaldegalerie, Berlin                                          Accademia, Venice
 

Madonna of the Cave 1465                             Madonna and Child Blessing 1510
Uffizi, Florence                                               Brera Gallery, Milan
    


Madonna and Child with St. John             Madonna and Child with Saints
Baptist and Magdalene 1500 NGL            Catherine and Magdalene 1490
                                                                              Accademia, Venice
 


                                                            
Pala Trivulzio 1497                                              San Giobbe Altarpiece, 1480-88
Castello Sforzesca, Milano                                  Accademia, Venice

                                                                                       







A comparison of St. Sebastians:
                                                                                       San Giobbe, 1480-88
Louvre, 1480                                                                  Accademia, Venice



Half-length portraits
Cardinal Ludovico Trevisan  1459-60                     Doge Leonardo Loredan 1501
Gemaldegalerie, Berlin                                            NGL
                             

Christ Supported by Angels  1488                     Christ with Angels   1455
Staten Museum fur Kunst, Copenhagen            Gemaldegalerie, Berlin                            


Crucifixion (San Zeno Altarpiece) 1457-60    Crucifixion with John and Mary
Basilica di San Zeno, Verona                           Louvre, Paris 1465-70

 
  

                                          
Early Altarpieces:                                                       Pala di Pesaro 1474
San Zeno Altarpiece 1457-60                                     Museo Civico di Pesaro, 
Basilica di San Zeno, Verona                                      Pesaro, Italy
                                                  

Horizontal Altarpieces:

Adoration of the Shepherds 1450-51        Barbarigo Altarpiece 1488
Met Museum, New York                           San Pietro Martire, Murano, Italy


Late Altarpieces:
 
Madonna della Vittoria 1496                                            Frari Altarpiece, 1488
Louvre, Paris                                                                  Basilica di Santa Maria
                                                                                       dei Frari, Venice

                                                                                San Zaccaria Altarpiece, 1505
                                                                                San Zaccaria, Venice